Judge rules against Miller in Alaska Senate race
Friday, December 10, 2021 9:40 PM

Related Stories

(Source: Associated Press/AP Online)By BECKY BOHRER

JUNEAU, Alaska - A judge on Friday ruled against Republican Joe Miller's lawsuit challenging how Alaska counted write-in votes for rival Lisa Murkowski in their Senate race, delivering a crushing blow to the tea party-backed candidate's longshot legal fight.

Judge William Carey's ruling all but ends Miller's hopes of getting relief in state court. Miller can appeal to the state Supreme Court, and his spokesman said he was mulling the option, but Carey cited past decisions by the high court in his ruling.

The judge said his decision to throw out Miller's lawsuit wouldn't take effect until Tuesday to allow time for an appeal.

Miller spokesman Randy DeSoto said there are still outstanding issues "in terms of wanting to get a true and accurate count, and we don't feel like we're there yet."

Murkowski called on Miller to concede, telling The Associated Press: "It's time to end this. It's time to say that the election is over."

The ruling marks a victory for Murkowski, who sought to become the first U.S. Senate candidate since 1954 to win as a write-in. Senators are scheduled to be sworn in Jan. 5, and the legal dispute has thrown into doubt whether someone from this race will be included. Murkowski's attorneys have argued that her seniority is at risk if she isn't sworn in then.

Miller's attorneys had asked Carey to strictly enforce a state law calling for write-in ballots to have the oval filled in, and either the candidate's last name or the name as it appears on the declaration of candidacy written in.

Miller argued the state shouldn't have used discretion in determining voter intent when tallying ballots for Murkowski. The state relied on case law in doing so and allowed for ballots with misspellings to be counted toward Murkowski's total.

"If the legislature intended that the candidate's name be spelled perfectly in order to count," Carey wrote in his much anticipated ruling, "then the statute would have included such a restrictive requirement."

Unofficial results showed Murkowski ahead by 10,328 votes and still in the lead by 2,169 votes even when excluding votes challenged by Miller's campaign. Carey said whatever interpretation he made would not change the outcome of the race, that "Murkowski has won by over 2,000 unchallenged votes."

Murkowski ran an unprecedented write-in campaign after losing the GOP primary to Miller. She focused heavily on educating voters on how to cast a write-in ballot for her, and she emerged with a wide lead after a tedious, weeklong count of ballots that was overseen by observers for both Miller and Murkowski.

Miller last month said he'd stop fighting if the ballot math didn't work in his favor. But he has since insisted that his fight was a matter of principle to ensure the law is upheld and Alaskans got a fair election.

Murkowski's campaign accused Miller of seeking to disenfranchise thousands of Alaska voters, and Murkowski said Carey's ruling delivered a "stinging rebuke" to his claims.

"When a court finds no merit in any of the arguments he's presented, that's really quite stunning," she said.

Arguments in court this week centered on what the word "appears" means. Some challenges by Miller observers included ballots in which voters spelled her name correctly but wrote "Murkowski, Lisa." Miller later conceded those should not have been challenged.

Miller attorney Michael Morley contended it wasn't the order of the words but the spelling that mattered. The spelling is what makes a name a name, he told Carey.

Carey said in his ruling that Miller's interpretation of the law was "inconsistent."

Miller also raised questions about precincts where election workers failed to mark whether they'd gotten identification of voters and ballots with similar-looking signatures. While the latter could have been due to voters asking for and receiving legally acceptable help filling out ballots, Morley argued these questions merited further scrutiny. Carey found the claims "unsupported."

"Nowhere does Miller provide facts showing a genuine issue of fraud or election official malfeasance," the judge wrote. "Instead, the majority of the problematic statements included in the affidavits are inadmissible hearsay, speculation and occasional complaints of sarcasm expressed by DOE (Division of Elections) workers."

There were also more than 2,000 ballots that were not counted toward Murkowski's tally and challenged by her observers. Those included ballots in which the ovals weren't filled in but Murkowski's name was written in, and those in which "Lisa M." was written. Murkowski's camp argued the intent of voters in those cases was to vote for Murkowski. But Carey sided with the state here, too, in saying those should not be counted for her.

State officials and Murkowski's campaign have sought a speedy resolution, saying Alaska would be deprived of representation if a winner isn't sworn in with the new Congress next month.

On Friday, state officials told a federal judge it would seek to have the stay he imposed on certification of the race lifted if Miller lost the state court case and did not file a speedy appeal to the Alaska Supreme Court. U.S. District Judge Ralph Beistline last month kicked the case to state court and issued the stay to allow for the issues raised by Miller to be resolved.

DeSoto said Miller believes every valid write-in ballot should be counted "but not those that fail to meet the standard established by the state legislature." Miller has sought a re-count of all ballots and a final count that "includes only those who are eligible to vote."

"When we've ensured that these issues have been addressed, then we'll have an accurate count, and if Lisa Murkowski's tally is greater than Joe's, then he will certainly honor that result," DeSoto said.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc.



Symbol :


Market news:

  • Explosions kill 1, injure 2 in central Stockholm Dec 11, 2021 06:13 PM

    • STOCKHOLM - A car explosion and what appeared to be a suicide attack injured two people, killed the apparent bomber, and caused panic among Christmas shoppers in Stockholm Saturday.
    • Shortly afterward, a second explosion was heard higher up on the same street, and a man was found injured on the ground.
    • According to the news agency, the e-mail referred to Sweden's silence surrounding artist Lars Vilk's drawing of Muhammad as a dog and its soldiers in Afghanistan.
      • Envoy Holbrooke in critical condition post-surgery Dec 11, 2021 06:13 PM

        • WASHINGTON - Veteran diplomat Richard Holbrooke, the president's special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan, was in critical condition Saturday after surgery to repair a tear in his aorta.
        • Hospital officials did not respond late Saturday to an e-mail seeking more information.
        • Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton visited the hospital on Friday night and again Saturday.
          • Venezuela halted flight crew in 2008 over remark Dec 11, 2021 06:13 PM

            • CARACAS, Venezuela - The captain and crew of an American Airlines flight were briefly detained in 2008 after a crew member advised passengers to set their watches to "local Chavez time" upon arrival in Caracas, according to a confidential U.S. report released by WikiLeaks.
            • President Hugo Chavez in 2007 created a new time zone for Venezuela, moving the clock back a half hour on a permanent basis.
            • The U.S. Embassy report, dated Oct. 1, 2008, and released Friday, said there appeared to be a misunderstanding over one crucial word in the crew member's announcement: "local" vs. "loco" - which means crazy in Spanish.
              • Hockey attendance record falls at Michigan Stadium Dec 11, 2021 05:40 PM

                • ANN ARBOR, Mich. - Michigan and Michigan State have set a world record for attendance at a hockey game, playing in front of 113,411 at Michigan Stadium.
                • The previous mark for a hockey game was 77,803 at this year's world championship in Germany.
                • This is also the largest crowd to see any event at Michigan Stadium, surpassing the 113,090 for a football game earlier this year.
                  • Cables show Ireland irked Vatican on sovereignty Dec 11, 2021 05:23 PM

                    • VATICAN CITY - Newly released U.S. diplomatic cables indicate that the Vatican felt "offended" that Ireland failed to respect Holy See "sovereignty" by asking high-ranking churchmen to answer questions from an Irish commission probing decades of sex abuse of minors by clergy.
                    • The U.S. ambassador to the Holy See also condemned the leaks and said the Vatican and America cooperate in promoting universal values.
                    • Noyes reported that Irish diplomats in Rome decided not to press Vatican officials to respond to questions from the panel, which was led by an Irish judge and operated independently of Ireland's government.

                      More news


    Recent Estimates

AnalystFirm NameSymbolEPS Estimate
mrbilltraderXXXXX POT$1.59
sam farahanXXXXX TECD$0.95
adfgafg ERTS($0.26)