Neglect threatens many of Italy's cherished ruins
Tuesday, November 09, 2021 8:10 PM

Related Stories

(Source: Associated Press/AP Online)By FRANCES D'EMILIO

ROME - For all of Italy's ancient wonders, the real wonder might be that so many are still standing, given the poor care they get. The collapse in Pompeii last week of a frescoed house where gladiators prepared for combat was the latest loss. The structure had survived the explosion of Mount Vesuvius in 79 A.D. but apparently could not withstand modern neglect.

"We're stunned when some walls fall down. But these are ruins not systematically maintained, so the miracle is that so few of them collapse," said Andrea Carandini, a world-renowned archaeologist who leads a panel of professional consultants in the Cultural Ministry.

Last spring, a huge segment of Nero's fabled Golden Palace beneath Rome gave way, raining down pieces of vaulted ceiling in one of the galleries under a garden popular with strollers. Three years ago, a 20-foot (6-meter) section of ancient wall crumpled into a pile of bricks after days of heavy rain. The wall had been named after the third century emperor Aurelius, who built it to defend Rome against the first onslaught of barbarians.

A couple of months ago, three chunks of mortar broke off the Colosseum, hours before the symbol of the Eternal City opened its gates to tourists.

The ancient Roman arena has survived earthquakes, lightning strikes and pillaging, but these days engineers fret more about damage from pollution, the constant rattling of nearby subway rails and centuries of poor drainage.

Topping experts' list of imperiled structures is Palatine Hill, the once-palatial home of Rome's ancient emperors. For years, archaeologists and engineers have warned that it was at risk of collapse because of poor upkeep.

Fissures are apparent in brickwork, and rainwater seeps through stone, forcing much of the hall to be closed to visitors.

A building called the House of the Chaste Lovers collapsed in January in Pompeii, which is visited by 3 million tourists each year.

"We are tired of commenting on the continuous collapses and damage to the archaeological heritage of our country," said Giorgia Leoni, president of the Italian Confederation of Archaeologists in a statement after the gladiators' place fell apart on Saturday.

On Tuesday, Italian President Giorgio Napolitano decried what he called "terrible negligence" as a chief reason for national embarrassments like the Pompeii collapse.

Carandini, interviewed on Italian radio, warned that, should Pompeii be hard hit by an earthquake, "we wouldn't be able to do a (complete) restoration" because no relief map has ever been made of the site. The Naples area, which hosts the ruins, is one of Italy's most earthquake-prone regions.

Lovers of antiquities have long bemoaned the chronic shortage of funding to shore up shaky structures and save them for posterity.

Italy's Cultural Ministry, which is responsible for repairing ancient monuments and artworks, gets a mere 0.18 percent of the national budget, compared to roughly 1 percent for France, according to ministry officials.

It's a startling contrast for a nation that boasts the world's highest number of ruins, churches, monasteries and other artistic and architectural treasures. Those sites make tourism one of Italy's biggest industries.

Ironically, experts describe Italy as being a leader in preservation for pinpointing possible problems and drawing up a "kind of map of risk."

Giorgio Croci, one of Italy's best-known engineers for structural problems, said the nation's know-how is so in demand that Turkey has commissioned him to study Istanbul's monuments for potential perils.

Greece, with its legacy of ancient marvels, seems to do a better job at keeping their treasures intact.

On the whole, Greek sites have benefited from well-funded restoration and conservation program over the past decades. Although Greece is staggering through a severe economic crisis, work has continued on the Acropolis, where pieces of marble temples and monumental gates have been painstakingly sorted out and reassembled.

That work started after experts realized, in the 1970s, that quick action was needed because of worsening pollution and damage from past restorations.

In Italy, private sponsors, ranging from utility companies to mattress manufacturers, fill some of the gap. But they pick and choose, often "adopting" only the most high-profile projects.

Croci said the Pompeii collapse might have been avoided with simple, affordable measures - such as injecting material to encourage cohesion in the stone or simply covering the structure with some kind of shelter.

"A lot of the interventions are not that costly," said Croci, who has mapped out weak spots in the Colosseum and Palatine Hill ruins.

In Pompeii, the gladiators' house was repaired in 1947 after being damaged by bombing during World War II, and the use of reinforced concrete in that restoration was cited by some as a possible cause for the collapse.

Inspecting the wreckage on Tuesday, Pompeii's recently appointed superintendent, Jeannette Papadopoulos, said reinforced concrete was "slowly" being removed from some of the earlier restorations but that "unfortunately" restorers had not gotten around to tackling the gladiators' building.

Croci, who has not inspected the collapsed house, disagreed, citing infiltration of rainwater rather than concrete as the more likely culprit.


Associated Press Writer Nicholas Paphitis in Athens contributed to this report.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc.



Symbol :


Market news:

  • Deficit panel leaders' plan curbs Social Security Nov 10, 2021 03:55 PM

    • WASHINGTON - The leaders of President Barack Obama's bipartisan deficit commission launched a daring assault on mushrooming federal deficits on Wednesday, proposing reducing annual cost-of-living increases for Social Security, gradually raising the retirement age to 69 and taking aim at popular tax breaks such as the mortgage interest deduction.
    • It came a week after voters put Republicans back in charge of the House and told Washington that the government is too big.
    • The plan would also raise the regular Social Security retirement age to 68 in about 2050 and to 69 in 2075.
      • Write-in ballot count begins in Alaska Senate race Nov 10, 2021 03:55 PM

        • JUNEAU, Alaska - Misspellings and poor penmanship took center stage Wednesday in Alaska's contentious U.S. Senate race as teams of election workers began tallying more than 92,500 write-in ballots, with the two candidates' lawyers and observers intently watching the tedious process unfold.
        • Observers for GOP nominee Joe Miller - whose vote total trailed the number of write-in ballots cast in the Nov. 2 election by 11,333 as of Wednesday - were quick to challenge any ballot on which Sen. Lisa Murkowski's scribbled-in name was misspelled or letters were difficult to decipher.
        • Among the questions from Miller's team: Is that an "a" or an "o"?
          • Slow tow home for thousands on disabled ship Nov 10, 2021 03:47 PM

            • SAN DIEGO - Two tugboats slowly pulled a disabled cruise ship with nearly 4,500 passengers and crew toward San Diego on Wednesday.
            • The 952-foot Carnival Splendor crept into cell phone range and the onboard phone system started working on a limited basis, allowing passengers mostly cut off from communication since an engine fire Monday to finally reach their loved ones.
            • Officials said the ship could arrive in San Diego as early as mid-day Thursday.
              • Police: Mail bomb could have exploded over US Nov 10, 2021 03:47 PM

                • LONDON - A mail bomb intercepted last month at an English airport could have exploded over the East Coast of the United States, British police said Wednesday.
                • Forensic evidence showed the device, originally sent from Yemen by way of Cologne, Germany, was timed to be detonated about six to seven hours after the cargo aircraft carrying it left the U.K. for the U.S. The package was removed by police in Britain during transit.
                • "If the device had not been removed from the aircraft, the activation could have occurred over the eastern seaboard of the U.S.," police said in a statement.
                  • Thousands of UK students protest tuition fees hike Nov 10, 2021 03:47 PM

                    • LONDON - Tens of thousands of students marched through London on Wednesday against plans to triple university tuition fees, and violence erupted as a minority battled police and trashed a building containing the headquarters of the governing Conservative Party.
                    • As the march passed a high-rise building that houses Conservative headquarters, some protesters smashed windows as others lit a bonfire of placards outside the building.
                    • "We are destroying the building just like they are destroying our chances of affording higher education," said Corin Parkin, 20, a student at London's City University.

                      More news


    Recent Estimates

AnalystFirm NameSymbolEPS Estimate
adfgafg ERTS($0.26)
Dan Ruckn/a ADM$0.75