Pentagon trying to change culture to allow gays
Wednesday, October 20, 2021 7:07 PM

Related Stories



(Source: Associated Press/AP Online)By JULIE WATSON and ANNE FLAHERTY

SAN DIEGO - Beyond the courtroom arguments about "disrupting the troops" and "unit cohesion" are the nitty gritty details behind the Pentagon's fight to go slow on allowing openly gay troops.

Will straight and gay troops have to shower next to one another? Will the military have to provide benefits to gay partners, and can it afford to? And the biggest question of all: Will gays be harassed or intimidated?

It comes down to changing the culture, and top brass say they need more time. The military has been long resistant and, at times, hostile to gays, and it draws much of its 2.4 million members from socially conservative parts of the country.

"The real issues will be not what happens on the battlefield, but what happens on posts," said David R. Segal, a sociologist at the University of Maryland who has written extensively on the military's personnel policies and recruiting.

For many troops, "they don't mind suspecting their colleagues are gay, but they don't want to know for sure," he said.

Gay rights advocates say the government's efforts to overturn a federal judge's order halting the enforcement of "don't ask, don't tell" are unnecessary. They contend there were no huge eruptions of violence with the integration of women and blacks, even though the military had to contend with race riots among the ranks during the Vietnam War era.

Opponents of repeal point out that women have never been integrated into combat units. Women are still banned from many front-line units like infantry and special operations.

Advocates acknowledge that harassment will likely happen, just as it continues today with those groups. They say another aspect of military culture - following orders - will override any temptation to intimidate gays.

"If your commander-in-chief says this is the new law, then that's the way we follow it and we make it work," said David Hall, a former Air Force staff sergeant who was discharged under the 1993 Clinton-era policy.

Seeking to suspend or overturn U.S. District Judge Virginia Phillips' ruling leaves the administration arguing against its own policy goals and against the majority opinion among the Democratic base most likely to turn out for midterm elections next month.

Allowing the courts to steer the lifting of the ban leaves military leaders feeling rushed and misled. Top military officials thought they had bought time to prepare the uniformed forces, spouses, families and veterans for openly gay service.

Officials who spoke on condition of anonymity because the administration's path is still uncertain said the administration has never fully acknowledged that while a majority of Americans may want the ban lifted, a majority of the uniformed military might not.

Still, gays already serve in the military, many with the knowledge of colleagues who promise to protect their secret.

It was this fact that led the top uniformed officer, Adm. Mike Mullen, to tell a stunned Senate hearing room last February that the "don't ask, don't tell" law should be repealed.

"No matter how I look at this issue, I cannot escape being troubled by the fact that we have in place a policy which forces young men and women to lie about who they are in order to defend their fellow citizens," Mullen said. "For me personally, it comes down to integrity - theirs as individuals and ours as an institution."

But even as Mullen made his case before Congress, his fellow service chiefs, including the Army's Gen. George Casey and Marine Corps Commandant Gen. James Conway, were opposed to making any changes when the military is fighting large, protracted wars with its all-volunteer force.

Underlying their concern was the military's culture.

Unlike most Americans who support allowing openly gay troops, the rank-and-file are suspected by their leaders to be considerably less permissive.

The men and women serving in the armed forces today represent less than 1 percent of the country's total population, and come heavily from rural, conservative areas in the South and the mountain West.

Among their concerns was how to effectively implement new policies for sharing close quarters and living facilities.

Military officials say privately that the service chiefs worry most about a cultural backlash and displays of intolerance that would make the military look as if it had lost control of its troops.

If the military lifts the ban suddenly, would there be attacks on gays? Would religious parents, coaches and teachers who oppose gay rights persuade young recruits not to enlist? If a platoon member says he is gay, would his comrades still support him, or would there be infighting?

Conway, the Marine Corps commandant, claims, by his own informal survey of the force, some 90 to 95 percent oppose letting gays serve openly.

"We recruit a certain type of young American, pretty macho guy or gal, that is willing to go fight and perhaps die for their country," he said.

The experience in militaries of Britain, Canada and Israel showed that allowing openly gay service members was a "non-issue, non-event," said Lawrence Korb, a former assistant defense secretary who oversaw military manpower and reserve affairs during the Reagan era.

"Britain dropped the policy within a month," said Korb, now a senior fellow with the liberal Center for American Progress. "I can't believe that people, that Obama let himself fall into this idea that we got to do a study. Just do it!"

Korb said the Uniform Code of Military Justice also outlines how people should treat each other.

According to Segal, the sociologist, the true impact of Phillips' ruling that the policy was unconstitutional depends upon how many gay troops speak out about their sexuality and how military leaders respond to any dissent within the ranks.

Segal said he expects the cultural change will happen much like it did following President Harry Truman's 1948 executive order for military racial equality.

The first test of that notion didn't come until a couple of years later during the Korean War, when the U.S. was short on troops and all-black units were proving less capable. As a remedy, the Army fielded integrated units that eventually performed on par with all-white ones.

Still, the military grappled with racial violence.

According to a 1993 RAND study, the military enjoyed a certain level of racial harmony following that war. But the "veneer of racial harmony was shattered" in the late 1960s with the rise in racial tensions throughout the country. Race riots broke out in all four services.

"We will still have to deal with hate crimes," Segal said. "Fifty years from now, we'll have to deal with hate crimes. . . . It's going to take doing it (changing the law) and good leaders who are committed to making it work.

"Once the top level says 'This is where we go,' people are going to move in that direction."

---

Flaherty reported from Washington. Associated Press writer Anne Gearan in Washington contributed to this report.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc.

 

Sponsors

Symbol :

Advertisement

Market news:

  • Man, 73, rides lawnmower to spring dog from kennel Oct 23, 2021 08:27 PM

    • HYDRO, Okla. - An elderly Hydro man landed in jail after springing his prized pooch from the town kennel.
    • Instead of paying a $100 fine for not having his poodle on a leash, 73-year-old Edwin Fry decided to bust Buddy Tough out, driving his lawnmower to the city pound Oct. 13 and breaking into the cage with bolt cutters.
    • As the pair escaped, police officer Chris Chancellor intercepted them.
      • Motherhood generates talk in Okla. governor's race Oct 23, 2021 08:27 PM

        • EDMOND, Okla. - In her quest to become Oklahoma's first female governor, Democrat Jari Askins has amassed an assortment of professional qualifications: she's been a judge, a legislator, the head of a state agency, and a corporate attorney.
        • And as this historic race between two women candidates for the state's top office nears its conclusion, that gap in her biography is attracting increasing attention.
        • At rallies and other appearances, opponent Rep. Mary Fallin, 55, a Republican congressman, regularly mentions her new husband and their combined six children.
          • Leaked Iraq war files portray weak, divided nation Oct 23, 2021 08:27 PM

            • WASHINGTON - The enormous cache of secret war logs disclosed by the WikiLeaks website paints a picture of an Iraq burdened by persistent sectarian tension and meddling neighbors, suggesting that the country could drift into chaos once U.S. forces leave.
            • They appear to support arguments by some experts that the U.S. should keep thousands of troops there beyond their scheduled departure in 2011, to buy more time for Iraq to become stable.
            • Another example: On June 6, 2006, U.S. forces reported discovering large amounts of blood on the floor, a rubber hose and electric wires rigged to a metal door in a holding cell in an Iraqi police station in Husaybah, in western Iraq.
              • Cholera outbreak creeps closer to Haiti's capital Oct 23, 2021 08:18 PM

                • PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti - A spreading cholera outbreak in rural Haiti threatened to outpace aid groups as they stepped up efforts Saturday hoping to keep the disease from reaching the squalid camps of earthquake survivors in Port-au-Prince.
                • Health officials said at least 208 people had died and 2,674 others were infected in an outbreak mostly centered in the Artibonite region north of the capital.
                • "If the epidemic makes its way to Port-au-Prince, where children and families are living in unsanitary, overcrowded camps, the results could be disastrous," said Dr. Estrella Serrano, World Vision's emergency response health and nutrition manager.
                  • Gunmen kill 13 in massacre at a party in Mexico Oct 23, 2021 07:41 PM

                    • CIUDAD JUAREZ, Mexico - Gunmen stormed two neighboring homes and massacred 13 young people at a birthday party in the latest large-scale attack in this violent border city, even as a new government strategy seeks to restore order with social programs and massive police deployments.
                    • Attackers in two vehicles pulled up to the houses in a lower-middle-class Ciudad Juarez neighborhood late Friday and opened fire on about four dozen partygoers gathered for a 15-year-old boy's birthday party.
                    • The majority of the victims were high school students, a survivor said.

                      More news


Advertisement

    Recent Estimates

AnalystFirm NameSymbolEPS Estimate
XXXXXXXXXX PQ$0.12
XXXXXXXXXX NFLX$0.72
XXXXXXXXXX ATW$0.92
XXXXXXXXXX UPS$0.87
XXXXXXXXXX PFE$0.51
XXXXXXXXXX JDAS$0.39
Frank CastleCar INC. FHN($0.02)
XXXXXXXXXX AMZN$0.48
XXXXXXXXXX PAY$0.32
XXXXXXXXXX JPM$0.91