Judge orders lesbian reinstated to Air Force
Friday, September 24, 2021 7:45 PM

Related Stories



(Source: Associated Press/AP Online)By GENE JOHNSON

TACOMA, Wash. - A federal judge ruled Friday that a decorated flight nurse discharged from the Air Force for being gay should be given her job back as soon as possible in the latest legal setback to the military's "don't ask, don't tell" policy.

The decision by U.S. District Judge Ronald Leighton came in a closely watched case as a tense debate has been playing out over the policy. Senate Republicans blocked an effort to lift the ban this week, but Leighton is now the second federal judge this month to deem the policy unconstitutional.

Maj. Margaret Witt was suspended in 2004 and subsequently discharged under the "don't ask, don't tell" policy after the Air Force learned she had been in a long-term relationship with a civilian woman. She sued to get her job back.

Leighton hailed her as a "central figure in a long-term, highly charged civil rights movement." Tears streaked down Witt's cheeks and she hugged her parents, her partner and supporters following the ruling.

"Today you have won a victory in that struggle, the depth and duration of which will be determined by other judicial officers and hopefully soon the political branches of government," the judge told her, choking up as he recalled Witt's dramatic testimony about her struggles.

The ruling was the second legal victory this month for opponents of "don't ask, don't tell," and it throws the law into further disarray.

A federal judge in California earlier this month ruled the law unconstitutional and is considering whether to immediately halt the ban, and now Witt will be allowed to return to the military despite being openly gay.

The 1993 law prohibits the military from asking about the sexual orientation of service members, but allows the discharge of those who acknowledge being gay or are discovered engaging in homosexual activity.

The Justice Department did not immediately comment on the ruling, but James Lobsenz, Witt's attorney, said he expected an appeal.

In 2006, Leighton rejected Witt's claims that the Air Force violated her rights, following prior precedent that the military's policy on gays is constitutional. An appeals court panel overruled him two years later, holding that in light of a Supreme Court ruling striking down a Texas ban on sodomy, "don't ask, don't tell" intrudes on the rights of gay service members. For the government to discharge gays it must prove that their firings further military goals, the panel said.

Leighton determined after a six-day trial that Witt's discharge advanced no legitimate military interest. To the contrary, her dismissal hurt morale in her unit and weakened the squadron's ability to carry out its mission, he ruled.

"There is no evidence that wounded troops care about the sexual orientation of the flight nurse or medical technician tending to their wounds," Leighton ruled.

Gay rights advocates welcomed the ruling, saying that if the government must justify each firing under "don't ask," it will mean a slow death for the policy.

Leighton became emotional as he recalled Witt's testimony about the support she has received from her parents since she came out to them on the eve of filing her lawsuit.

"The best thing to come out of all this tumult is still that love and support," he said.

A crowd of spectators remained quiet until the judge left the courtroom, when it erupted in cheers.

"I'm just so thrilled I have the chance to do what I wanted to do all along: that's return to my unit," Witt said.

She also said that she appreciated the judge's recognition of the many gays who continue to quietly serve in the military.

---

Associated Press writer Julie Watson contributed from San Diego.

A service of YellowBrix, Inc.

 

Sponsors

Symbol :

Advertisement

Market news:

  • Obama to rally thousands of voters in Philadelphia Oct 10, 2021 03:28 AM

    • WASHINGTON - President Barack Obama headlines a rally in Philadelphia on Sunday, hoping to re-ignite the type of Democratic enthusiasm that carried him to victory two years ago.
    • Vice President Joe Biden will join Obama in the Germantown community, where the hip-hop band the Roots will warm up the crowd.
    • It's the second of four large rallies designed to recapture some of the big-stage excitement that Obama created in 2008 with stirring speeches to thousands of young and first-time voters.
      • End to currency dispute eludes finance ministers Oct 10, 2021 03:28 AM

        • WASHINGTON - Differences that threaten the outbreak of a currency war persisted after a weekend meeting of global finance ministers, who left without resolving what to do.
        • The G-20 includes traditional economic powers such as the United States and Europe along with fast-growing economies such as China, Brazil and India.
        • "Currency disputes can easily become trade disputes," cautioned Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty.
          • Yankees beat Twins 6-1 to return to ALCS Oct 10, 2021 03:28 AM

            • NEW YORK - Mariano Rivera got the last out, sealing yet another October triumph.
            • Jorge Posada trotted out to mound, and the Yankees came out of the dugout in a businesslike manner to shake each other's hands.
            • Two more to go before the New York Yankees' big party can start.
              • Anti-gay torture allegations stun neighbors in NYC Oct 10, 2021 03:20 AM

                • NEW YORK - Allegations that gang members attacked two teens and a man last week because they were gay don't square with the reputation of their Bronx neighborhood, where gay men and women live openly and neighbors are tolerant of homosexuality, residents and city leaders said.
                • One teen even called the suspects themselves "chill," though she and other neighbors said the gang members often partied and were violent when drinking.
                • Eight suspects have been arrested, and a ninth was at large early Sunday.
                  • No new cracks found on red sludge pool in Hungary Oct 10, 2021 02:57 AM

                    • DEVECSER, Hungary - Officials in Hungary say no new cracks have been detected overnight on the north wall of the red sludge reservoir which was thought to be close to collapse and that the situation is "hopeful."
                    • Disaster agency spokesman Tibor Dobson has told The Associated Press on Sunday that the older cracks are being repaired but that it is too soon to consider lowering the current state of alert.
                    • Protective walls also are being built around the reservoir's damaged area to hold back any further spills.

                      More news


Advertisement

    Recent Estimates

AnalystFirm NameSymbolEPS Estimate
alfred bloomingdaleXXXXX RFMD$0.14
r morriseyXXXXX RFMD$0.14
johnorganization MU$0.40
XXXXXXXXXX BLUD$0.30
KyprosIndividual AA$0.06
XXXXXXXXXX X$0.30
XXXXXXXXXX FFIV$0.55
XXXXXXXXXX CREE$0.54
gofasterstripesMr Lak CTXS$0.25
XXXXXXXXXX TOT$1.52